EaOrooelury4fyiu sglme5tteyn ah0pst re h(i stbc bte hl chbe Gee deenH aa gfgaimmotpvteirheeepen as rio oaa,hnnf gfs is) t sei oaoh tn m tfoveki a mgeEiwfinl lue3sirgoss.e0’r ts k0 Photo: Matthias Kabel mtbnhur4uelat0m nia0pcbcl hteybueric ans oI lgo fnn f bf utrayhum eitvbt hi kIebeannrh n.don idTitwua ahmllnkeeis abade vegiptsereri esc to ie hfs(t e2 hbtk 0ewyfie9 pirMcg5stotsa fu .shrr eneuTactchibritoeehn r atagde”nr es,atd tdhts ia e5mae, y0x ansK a0tu iemt0mnh 0pgibes 0l e eRaf0r otc 0ououc fpnonl esau daaarn nmv ttseoa.pis nleb)ig sneolt geinvm e t–twra wy“ti ebogcsu ,lg otttr shheteeeha n itts o LuRakodem ’7sa t nGrCa oepvsnerpsoleu vtlsio n ab csBye e c Qtoahuuf liseJriiuhnndeguem sJa, o, t gsoioes b pvmeeh re tnanaontxrideo odnMf.e atdrhy ei nt o Roman Gudyma/iStock/Thinkstock T i m e l i n e o f b1ozoo0dkti hab cycs. e CInitct euisrr oya, p Tsphthaeor ewenast rltlyihe eisan tmt keonnvodewemdne fngotrrsa upotshfe ,t ihinne amp lociaonnmaestmtse ertnyht srasocruyhg oohon lt sha. e t i c s thWce1ea 1nfile8sruss8 ts c Gpooeomfr paWpulladleal teotesifdo. n puy1rSpe3oaqM ab0trureeoas3at bfr htleAuiaholsnt iedt”Ced y hreaCs, ii hmihgnanoahene wrtstndthhest et o a dthp flhw i oaattetweohg s beaertta pirh nS map–eeose v memtaPehnriaaneaetst idl chMt n claefiueuolmvmd’leste a fib“t pfithTerilcichruyaissieenn n ntdogOghtrfl les ead d.t i1n3fo4Cr6armon Gnadtii ocitoarvan agd noienvn eio stfV hisFletllo aaptrneoiisnp’stcui cNelaa.u lto iovan byggarn79/iStock/Thinkstock 17409713, 2013, 6, Downloaded from https://rss.onlinelibrary.w 500 400 300 200 100 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 800 900 1000 1100 1200 1300 1400 1500 1600 1700 1800 1900 2000 iley.com Mat1och5fab4h nl6eydec3wu 0iwuimd1fgmaf lfai oGahesfbbrtrf tera cet eee c rgaorrsAonat eoakf illtto pnecamf tcof drunmta tanob bilc hscoaebltkrleeoeot iae rcbCel bflrsdtkba ras.oihtiisreld echd.irb udktr oetaeTsi ehw en.anshhr esioslseTeel d o hmigncgweaieoohn eeumsttgddtn i o o ePotltsfdi lh ktwan t eetthafmolsarseye e . sqr tawceMou aapi eunllcenell a ta ttbiltt hpchyveeul aedy cll Paiouwsnetueegealv no l(eltitptsthirho. naebengl y ln tme tietnhmhoiStock/Thinkstocksgeiedea t eshn ) iStock/Thinkstock Hafshardtooni l2mu lpat d sa hcebCiheyFwnntoeoh1onehahh dnopiu6rvaogen imsrltesl5cat eyie dtm odhamd 4 sbysoiegt eia n ebd vfrePfi– tce elaictah p1niodndhtetnser2driah necognrmab.s eearsb3 gs cy a ugsl5ua6cc fi ptsas7sarrbu imr otevmccn.sirua6ainhlaatidevniklt 7dotltl esecde eyi lm soesea .., nnrri slas tl unihtosoden u1s6teop6s o 3eppLs auJotroilnimahsdthanoio t nreGne. r ctaohoufre nd ts Brian Jackson/iStock/Thinkstock lactro1ghyneo7ej eu1nmc 3purtoea rmJrepneabded ceiaaico rtcdtsb c a e tu–Bnrhri eaevtehrt exnreesepol ysetmuu hrlyoileltmoir .’euslea nAowctafr ,tsno e f n cGtohe1iner7m s4i nrat9uhnfo ne,Gr Smoawt taoanttfrtairditois ietn“oids kn yt)A ao;s ctuthiha senett eniemc.ewsedt”aoaah lfnt1n(el o idcso7Bn or6a taenhy1nmdee disT t –t hhiep oeytsrn hoptRaievonel et gvcphs.o r eoBroTsfnhabe ebyoasree.mbsoeslrit1iafe’ltoe i 7sccctfinf l;soy8seer t rts9r udhtg d seGys y mnio dlofobea fwetnt earc-dtm nlr iioWamsp ptehlausartir atteaaeet lnur ciJ dasrh“uoten 1sasschstd7n eu,ank fg9ctodeA uiekS1teascl.ohi tptcnfoFeieo occisrsurrsl , s an” ti t ri un ois nfEe Sn hocgiofsl ti tslShahtena, dtwbi.syot 8riSfcdfs4oisar yre0erl m qc tIrubhseeoeltAanl smmcrc aoyioibnd cdsai eetcfanmcs ur oca.inanc– vonluAtoyde mthmtsdvlasr-h1eiima emeKsbtem8rd rhioeui –a0n aabenntm ldtt8ei stt iionielh la oc eltGnoselai-not assasr ltt ams nmhuaoeEfog asrnru aoA eostspdlrish ,lt mnoest -–w dheecwt pdK iec1 iTrirLtse ilsioeo rrcon8ltta.t“eon dmurh dupa3saricburm .tibdvlmt5ev craaieyuueae escno rsBtasse seoadnitesk e ,ogfa o s l niteg nni is dmaMteniaacx nsnA, ” daai no–nntl ddphr ohietsdhea ue rhQnc eceuiinosge gnhtssecto.el,Wce tpbicratatt1a’oalsh loec8uod efskfs4yfi .e es 0cdTtsi a h aWaorilntfs i sl dodlayi fesald ltamomietsw mheeFsda a i sifnercoerp a rsEsi pl dn recise1eagntofthcLsms18alsmaooifa o rs0to5uaifdrnmpnic fidr6 p4snodasd wscit 9W we rno,tiiJatae cw ahsgnnioovtDndstlle e, hil .du ok tibl sr–nalbd himt ea nmp eaye gSeggu t enossiditmssdonfohot apuwneamieyc ri np’ics ns CndiB– e ogdi“ onn eBlctotioh mhqrvfhEko euoeeina:a cesl nsgedstsmrtr loo.u aaoaoScrrrn u vtdktmordte e efboi.ayr ne rfn pet ”,a k d1ra1ow5fn 0c a oTtirn irasma lnf iordnofot memtdh ,t.e h i InePt yRficxoox, neyadatdtntmdil hihn paieMaoaaeuargyrnngo 1eitrcn nn rp as8ehMaeut umon6,t,mamoa r oc 8catbls tob hi n ocehtotueM hdofgeenkrn iiwsi Nisnsttndotl he aoa sfitsdoresp .mroheam “dtf ho Cod batyep’tiletseo.1wn htleosh naomri c8oegvseencsn e enr8ps ukstno a port’he t6,rcsutnpia fuhvreo ly f mh arleMrePo t ove ituiymh ahbrteac nuw p yeli erraeotrilepc averhap fhd yees en .t, r o t h-pfhme orL oioLodprondeindlssedtot ,oncC ntl”ha.h apsrArsoolr ueoeasgarn, hs 1dBht o 8woooetwfoo9v re pes set8ryearhoen oe l l Vttkddclbstholioiuheo ceynflcgekw.oor es isBl unP lfohsorioosnehr wiirtsd so k t s wAnton Snarikov/iStock/ahioe esnpThinkstockw rtPidehcrdiuazsi’tstsc sr taiidabapabnuptlt aaeair oreopmnnna.ytt ldt yfeer raornatm,rh e s Stttidsoeo whaTwneohehtvnafreahf al teeteadTlsyeot lta no l at hroistcp,uwawtedssehe flsrstttnaa iea o,..iim onycn sc s ybtslKe rhutsdF ahiaciiv svnrmaw tgecibo isaeeoepsi selfbtmsn n.wwee ra cietosnca s hhni ir m enneb tsaaaadith xgt.omtnnn aha eie. uddrsdgFen hro dtStar eyldoue eepe ttt. dagwnoana q rmbNoreattt. uc ul shioavgtsteiesSs hehuki ar ntaistoeseeertoinceattecsf rfeiy n tsais wd oisn fod sclnasnaahsd giirittme bresgr ei iatmeshw cnlinedo met taote tcar aa ilwehidpmdrhts lnb aaroeatt adauaedsous crdr nwst tuaationsditiosaerntn oclciirefgasadmdolena en i or ntwhsnlahsatdhiwn o,gta ekri -e i eoswtec ir n paneth or tLm gr e.k tehtmnaagy roihaoecfanrworupefidgr langucui lhpeecpese hmrs ea fsh o wia Hotte oehv unahtirsaan-aatetmrdet dnh servrir cir niwm o e saanoufostuh Shtnragns uriaoiteate ow gd l methaaCdtwnnyih shvneot i iat aefiheenltaliahyJpldhvtr icglireusa ny ed eawe plugs reesrn ibonyiertaseiunrcnesehrwue nseol gidecessmtd h asu o inuCa m t ecgbmnnhwim khatranheumaefie eniegmar tf,ymmr dtsaa ubhgdm ahf kbpzptiiarrrcoltniiauiokeaitinnanhdsit iramrrnngngaeeeeysst. /doi/10.1111/j.1740-9713.2013.00707.x by Cochrane Greece, Wiley Online Library on [13/10/2022]. See the T 1560 1580 1600 1620 1640 1660 1680 1700 1720 1740 1760 1780 1800 1820 1840 1860 1880 1900 1920 1940 1960 1980 2000 erm s and C emsBet1riaam5nh7as ett0t oae u rsAsrs ese otadsfrn uottdcnhhe oeep melalaroerrnciortea rhTttssymi .oic ennht sohi c oi sf d1bsreeh6aesotwo4trwfriw s4mose s rtteaM sahtnt.tieh e ciI Tesshtfio t aosriilcsseiefzta dlote lokhv fd no aeadafno n idtw pfadLifosn ea ttRs rnhagseognairnmbratctel pee en.h HGpetapr1O hoame6nebln s5e aRdfios7beu r oiiaslHlnuftis tvumoCbyeynho ngitcaonthelneokgnec dc osoeik ’nr snt.yi h s. e fdso1rotfirue6ehlrwnales9adr t 3a ta fieim tnrscEisotgoldtiyr np mtldd isaeuosaeleafnti tadtodlyh i v v fm Heteirarsaaa ibuptlEnleal enesoslyugis fs t rl pasaaotttrhnn eaiaedcoptg e niap–es. rat mHe–oitcshe ana t p ethlaohls eylfo.es fo a 1Ptfa7prhrr2iieeias8z nn et bddiV com okdwnloeetditna n sleli a;orty ehttC thteoaehemnnrayyddsn e aci hslmotvi hrsoeinen fsme fe tera ao rs tttifphhnaooeeglr tt m c mumtoanhasoteartir.k cteoe i aafti nn t1ht7hreua5 Fsd7tr e eaCne ahc sohaaf n,nn doaa nvtiniado ndbmaeealvc yiols omhitnategevs,re ya . Pla1y7fa8i6r iWntirlolidaumc es bb1yy7 m 93Teh.09no F mmoiranisls tlh i JoUoenSrfs fAecebemrsnaeocsrnukic ,sd ,ac intoraesu.kcnettensd gLmifveoeeg1rtne h8fi nos0tdedt5rti en oA ogfidf n lartoei reabco1nssud8te-ru 3Mvrscve3qaea u rsttTia oiehtor heenaes sB .ritish AssociaAa1tGsin8osrdoa3n ch9 Pwfiar:aoie mtlrTsli h oitBbdheneee e Acnli lsotm, mfAMeoenrari mdrcmtraeieenndwm .SV bCAtaeaalnertr snixBs.ae1tungi8rcdie4aeenl 9r Charles Babbage ommRpote1ciohnnCmh8yeritaa5boih rml“en9t NbSr.e aFtiyaSoganl nhfohmtd eirttW soe hittinnnhaesigcctre hteaAa chW l lma eNoeSas en iorurgfir o caiahrOscisl teetaftcifiit” nniewyr,c gsc eSof aau.ottmnl laoerSadeta hrii urn nsteucs thfl hnemisecuanshe a erefiosmltnr trw Ascsbaosthestef si e rcospot atvohducisefeceibu ars vltsapt ihiecilositoea efein se s .,s odn“dseevi1tsva atse8rrntili9aaodbb4npauld srteKd aesca rd dhdra,lei r -d6vePse8i eqaiv%anutiriada sootreoneifpond ”e.sn inat Inemodft sferep tontrsldhrte o fuseoor c sfwrme eiawsela rlahte chnle hine.et ho oLtwertaemrhitr temeathrwrli. lnhyo e 0.00.10.20.30.4 0.1−%3σ 2.1%−2σ13.6%−1σ34.1%µ34.1%1σ13.6%2σ2.1%3σ0.1% Mwtoews onditions (https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com sostrhfaoi fion1nmcnw dk9toa osh0lmn mee0tcac h i suraBLakallortee mo umstflwei aspu– n twcr Bhiittaachaeunyecema s h tam asiebstotol eaiinttcehrhisstroa e. invo nef Monkey Business/Thinkstock dfyct1eaohoavr9reruece 1 edlodoo6seuonp satDulsicyrg ubeo snrlt tmeiewfano rettig ucihsFs er etrt o ehtiiafcrdie smaea s lFrisee ziitlrscraeri skoaw at lln saLs W gb napt,aondoo trcb wtlahpudlreeert mersW sfad:tiu aeieiirlcrsfr. t Stthphoemr1e o aw9acdih2noduaan 4cirgtt ntrWied ooimaunln lse vctatneherntrniaa dtrl ts sigEsdncxseriitpecfieaevin1ctdroiait9ismilnntufi3tigetc5c n ia so wet.nRns xhd.H ip igs Aciewieshv.rs h i eD Fmrimseeic sesshowhniu dgeaatlentsryrs r e snao ornof e ffo t. a1d9v4tfiahn0resc-t e4G dp5e r rBoAmgalaayrannem s wTimauanrari tbnsilmtgea eate itlsE etnBciicltgesrmto canahni cldce ocyCdo oPemla,o prsukuss utciensrar,g. c tkhse pdrl1ooe9brgi4aivcb6eais llC itatohysx es’fsu r aomtxmhpieo tosmioirmsen mspo.fl e g5sas0eut10xhr9v0uee4a rwsyl8 ob-oo5mebf h3je5ea n0cTv,0thi ioi0evtu e mKcr .ida enAuansts elaeaay snro gRdonee,u -phltsaorucatrmaegtl raee,.n arefgcueachr1tvmraooao 9pnomrel5thuovtso0shetm b irotsoaitio dclnnaG e skdside seh atanebsoonti ac awJdwirh.am eeip splaTetranecogertvnruseoe c En htiuhiincr’esdso upqscsteuotaaamrtnlyiip,s t rtoywii nvchoaeafilnlc s ht.s Rainer Plendl/iStock/CbwThinkstockheshAactoador ltvmaeiasnsent asBiclc yeatshsmb esebeed anRc gpttoei oyoo paanfu lr. Se lSacT tmithaeioeotnimmncse tabgi scesr aoreMslwt .asS tl Iohtuthc, p lui aaeastnt, eyb d.rdo iosttsrtibr1au9ptp7ioi9nn g Bo,r hfccaa daowoad enmesmllrLmsiednitmoptipylghogeriuu pidnesnsEtntlt gsefeeeitB r drarh o”hay .wen,ep nnir Aasyao re dw sod iynm“ sn g aot’odatstbhr rfoimr aLloef ond omdf pdedie’mvaeslsy ureet fcteiocfiaol nieneadom rr,gcscs e fa i e tertd tn ,.e a ttah.e 1caado8ntv1erh 7e8srOeerc78aix lrs 8“aig”F bW t ecrhcieal ioeoososnn ndsfcir. eotnei mes Amgtt sratroGo te no aadstyifl nush t“iuCc oeGoDren nnuocesi,e won v ttDsrfodohrsoanes e rtrt” cm whhh ct–e eeeiovn d ntmawd’ hsclegee ueacsuaipetcgoen .trhuts .ihostb sI eeifeonn ssf , a“1pB9pi9ega7 Dr sTa htinae” p tfierirrnmstt . –2sM to0tbaofo0at n tis2tsheer tyeabPib cnaaOassul lalfl –lok t Dtrel“eameaslnPmal dstob h; det Aetherth mesfheot elsa refittt trouuliimcrcsnyesse . ”ss Peter Kim/iStock/Thinkstock e(cid:2)a(cid:2)sll(cid:6)uel(cid:4)(cid:7)2 (cid:1)(cid:5)cc50ct0ie(cid:4)1(cid:3)o(cid:4) (cid:1)ss2nst .f(cid:3)a(cid:7)N u(cid:7)(cid:2)tHal(cid:8)eletyse b ipnS(cid:7)(cid:7)e(cid:7)(cid:2)r(cid:9)i(cid:1) ecl(cid:6)tovdh(cid:4)emi(cid:10)e(cid:1)cr(cid:4)(cid:1)(cid:9) ,et(cid:10)U (cid:4)sss(cid:10)(cid:5) (cid:1)S (cid:10)tta ah(cid:4)(cid:4)P (cid:8)(cid:4)(cid:4)(cid:4)tme(cid:1)(cid:9)ri(cid:4) es(cid:4)(cid:9)er(cid:1)tsed(cid:2)ii(cid:5)(cid:8)csd(cid:8)i(cid:4)(cid:5)(cid:4)uai(cid:2)(cid:10)(cid:7)e(cid:23)a(cid:5)(cid:16)(cid:21) l(cid:8)(cid:22)n(cid:13)nts(cid:7)(cid:13)(cid:3) tt(cid:19)(cid:24),(cid:11)iia(cid:28)(cid:25) (cid:12)n(cid:14)(cid:3)a(cid:27)(cid:26)(cid:11)(cid:13)(cid:16)r(cid:11)(cid:7)(cid:27)(cid:15)(cid:29)(cid:17) l.(cid:13)(cid:12)(cid:13)(cid:4)(cid:19)(cid:13)(cid:14)(cid:7)(cid:30)(cid:26) (cid:4)(cid:21)(cid:10)(cid:20)(cid:3)(cid:18)(cid:31)(cid:13)(cid:13)(cid:3)(cid:6)(cid:13)(cid:4)(cid:4) /terms-and-conditions) on Wiley Online Library for rules of use; O A Modern19 e0r0a Photo: Sami Keinänen 1904 dn1eeusb9vcmr0erebi8rwbye ee Wrbs ro irlftefloh wisare am Gtmta1u -sStpi9teenleesa0nstsle8 .y e st IoqsGt u oieuansnsls lseDeyustu rg,bae ocl ioshtnmhdi,ea. aftl l 19IB1t1admifoMnn9oe2d evvdr,1ahrm ei t1gpacona enei fwto Hss dioen hnelrhuaeea r siUrmo etslbe rfSy awds uc pn ccsoiotul ioemolfnHnn m ebpmocsapsehalunaslucn-sea coctedyrlheaimys atirtr,stnhsed oea.e, 1 s 916 1920 ttp1hhop9aepht 3sus ei5telznhac eoGteo mio enolfoaedn rrnt sgg1lha aee–e 9r s– gZot2t ei hrbpi4siisevftr ye,dtfi rw,tan hlai decprnseneod e gtw t htshtehoaierms t ,o lse amnicszwi.a ett ny shoy oef 1928co1n9mfit3oed7sde tenJirnecnegr z .syi cnH iNteiesenr ytwvmiafiolarcskn 1is nlai9en ma3sttdrp2aosltid nitusogct .iecsa l Bundesarchiv, Bild 101I-783-0110-12/Dörner/CC-BY-SA1936 1940 paAbbrP elemeaDlt din1in2ae-oniuDt97nscnghm ta6k4td eys.phb4mer . r;eS isao tSnTrtprandsthadeena yutepirotci kca osfinaGsetsetr tedetitwgtecislr.hceysse m eaSf a r1nrhh.ayltro baeo an9Tamwteodw hn4itdix sea aloi4e mtl nlnt uitsyfoctako tsaeif n pitacrklpsayeolenn irl romg os oofit feobnwf up n crlt rre emFhacenhamrpeedeeoac t :iddwnhssuc oetc t rosahmereu pu2ire draeaiotc7 e l n en 0stys .o 1948 inantrdo1 dt9thu4oce 8e t“ shCb eilina td”fuoi dg–remi t fSauahlnt1 iaado9ngannem5 .to2ehnne toarly prfieu1ebsesabrpm9ecusnclrttai5ldoeocwatn0 k1 vboeBcihi esl9neepRreid asrngpc5ia.,hcdo o l6hacDtt fnsthooinaeigchr tdrsldhbaeidup or eul sielHunDngtiitnn evioeettle kglfiel hl l tey. 1960 Les Cunliffe/iStock/Thinkstock 196es4stttaritemi1assa9atttimv5coea8erd ln g Twtmihsva ieewyl ls Kio oodarfnkpo sj lcub atodenofgs–r tlsiMi.n1 v ageIe9 ti sse w6.ihrmh 8aipsc lCatherine Yeulet/he iStock/Thinkstock mopof1rd op9epal7 ora2trnit1 aiDdol9 a ntl7vihaki2edle hlcCiahoozonxaoc’sredd p. t wibnhodmtxira1coe-th1a9dda n9u i7said7chn6ne-7o swsaw Jhatssonhii shntdekhng ebsel rpeTo qu drxieuki-maapaegdarylotgr ioatel mfe.o s,r, 1980MadynoIsneDvsflito1ifssa-rp9upmnl8auadal2byait sl rioiEdoasfdtsnh i wQ,eof ousasn rear T dotnght ftrTie iandut paVg1afthti t9seinaivuc e.8ea w 4l 1lbe9eao8cdno8em rcM eltiasom1 r tgca9haatee8rlle 8fictf ohrTsraht n aawgctetoci.hrolednr Alejandro Catalá Rubio/iStock/Thinkstock spt“a1r1Ron9”9gd 9ria9sa3r 2md rTe mshlteeiaan tssgiets adltati,cin snagtloiu cwtaaog loa el . 19926id0ni0fgo2intr omaTnlhal-yetd i soiagunmir tposaatulos.nsrtee dso f 2000o2f0 mS0aig4gn aLizfiaicunanen.cche 20bs2oea0e0fcy 40“tosht 8nhteo he Hman asteiel sx sxtVtty aaat rtpetii anrsGont ofiy,ceo escsag shwrlieisoei”,ln. fl 2008 d2iecn0opv 13inrba2o.fisto5 beirTs oamemhobniesnniis ll-g elLil–it xiaoyi kirsan seg ort ceotefpo h unaHfiiancn2rvattedce0 di ica rodo1lsloefelnt2 n anetaw nhc CciHedeoth.yaihlgal r iadngdr csee er articles are governed by the applicable Creative Commons License